Created this for someone online.

I did a plain one
&

a embossed on.
Each one is made entirely in gimp from only 6 parts except the one with the circle. The guy wanted a Classic vintage camera look with the logo worked into it.
What do you think? Which one - if any would you choose?

I like the first Logo. The bump mapping in the second looks a little rough in places and I'm wondering if it might be better to play with the bevel filter instead. I think the lens will need to have some depth as well if you are going to use it.

Thanks Erisian I think I know what went wrong in part of the bumped one. I will try the bevel filter instead.

Thank you Conbagui