Switch to full style
Ask all general Gimp related questions here
Post a reply

Please Help, I Cannot get the correct value using the color picker.

Thu Jan 07, 2021 8:49 am

GIMP Version: 2.10.22
Operating System: Windows
OS Version: win7
GIMP Experience: Basic Level



I have two color areas (0, 0, 0) and (128, 128, 128).Then I set the pick radius of the color picker to 30 pixels. But I keep getting (91,91,91) instead of (64,64,64).
I think it may be related to the composition space, because I have to manually set the layer composition space to sensory every time. Otherwise, it will be linear light.(Sorry for my english, i used google translate.I don’t know if it expresses clearly,) .

Re: Please Help, I Cannot get the correct value using the color picker

Thu Jan 07, 2021 5:40 pm

ShangZhou wrote:GIMP Version: 2.10.22
Operating System: Windows
OS Version: win7
GIMP Experience: Basic Level



I have two color areas (0, 0, 0) and (128, 128, 128).Then I set the pick radius of the color picker to 30 pixels. But I keep getting (91,91,91) instead of (64,64,64).
I think it may be related to the composition space, because I have to manually set the layer composition space to sensory every time. Otherwise, it will be linear light.(Sorry for my english, i used google translate.I don’t know if it expresses clearly,) .


Well, no... You are considering light as a linear phenomenon, while your actual perception is logarithmic.

Try this: Create 3 images side by side on your screen. Fill the leftmost wih 91, the right most with 64, and fill the middle one with a small checker board (or thin stripes of equal width) of black (0) and 50% gray (128). No go tp the other side of the room and look at your screen. On xhich side is the image that looks like the center one?

So the average of 0 and 128 (in other words, the overall color of an image that is half black and half mid-gray) is 91 and not 64 a,d that what the color picker is telling you.

Re: Please Help, I Cannot get the correct value using the color picker

Thu Jan 07, 2021 8:02 pm

ofnuts wrote:
ShangZhou wrote:GIMP Version: 2.10.22
Operating System: Windows
OS Version: win7
GIMP Experience: Basic Level



I have two color areas (0, 0, 0) and (128, 128, 128).Then I set the pick radius of the color picker to 30 pixels. But I keep getting (91,91,91) instead of (64,64,64).
I think it may be related to the composition space, because I have to manually set the layer composition space to sensory every time. Otherwise, it will be linear light.(Sorry for my english, i used google translate.I don’t know if it expresses clearly,) .


Well, no... You are considering light as a linear phenomenon, while your actual perception is logarithmic.

Try this: Create 3 images side by side on your screen. Fill the leftmost wih 91, the right most with 64, and fill the middle one with a small checker board (or thin stripes of equal width) of black (0) and 50% gray (128). No go tp the other side of the room and look at your screen. On xhich side is the image that looks like the center one?

So the average of 0 and 128 (in other words, the overall color of an image that is half black and half mid-gray) is 91 and not 64 a,d that what the color picker is telling you.


xd,Well,Thank you, I learned some new knowledge. . But is there a way to make it give me the result of (64, 64, 64). I use GIMP to do some digital painting. This is very important to my workflow.

Re: Please Help, I Cannot get the correct value using the color picker

Thu Jan 07, 2021 9:33 pm

Just doubleclick on your foreground color and type in the values.

Re: Please Help, I Cannot get the correct value using the color picker

Thu Jan 07, 2021 10:10 pm

lylejk wrote:Just doubleclick on your foreground color and type in the values.

Lol , my fault ,or you just kidding. I mean let the color picker give me the linear result. But I have found an alternative method for my workflow, so if there is no way, it's okay, though,just it's not so convenient.....
Post a reply