GIMP Version: 2.8.14
Operating System: Windows
GIMP Experience: New User

List any ERROR messages you received:
path

---

Did anyone solve the GAP 2.7 & MPlayer connection, when attempting to extract images from a movie?
It says GAP_MPLAYER_APP ...how GAP connects to MPLAYER, if when MPLAYER is already installed in Win10?!
Thanx

I don't know the solution to this problem (I suppose only Linux will handle the * .sh file)
I have tried repeatedly (for gimp-2.8 and 2.10) but for Windows it does not work (unrecognized * .sh file)
For Gimp-2.10.20 and Windows10 only Extract Videorange works.

The sh file is a 'shell script'. You need 'bash' in your path.

Point of interest.
"Bash is the shell, or command language interpreter, for the GNU operating system. The name is an acronym for the ‘Bourne-Again SHell’, a pun on Stephen Bourne, the author of the direct ancestor of the current Unix shell sh, which appeared in the Seventh Edition Bell Labs Research version of Unix".

Another point of interest.
'GNU' stands for 'GNU's not Unix'.

A small experiment:
I changed sh to bat, launched it and mplayer unpacked the files into the folder (tmp; FILE 00000001.png ...00000100.png) - not very useful (because it did not open in Gimp) - it is better to use Extract Videorange.
It's possible that this only works with Mplayer 1.0 rc5 but I can't find it for Windows.

I've never used GAP before and don't know anything about it. Reading this thread tells me it's a plugin to extract frames using a video player and load those frames into Gimp as layers. I assume it's to edit those frames. There are tools much better suited for this, such as Video Editors.

If one needs to extract video frames as PNG files that can be imported into Gimp, there are a number of options such as ffmpeg. Here is a command to extract a range of frames in a video into an image-sequence. It stipulates to start the capture at the 23 sec mark and extract 4 sec of video.


A real Video Editor is still the recommended way to go...

Hi racer. I have to agree with you about video editors. GAP also makes another menu entry in Gimp Filters above G'MIC called 'Filter all Layers'. I found this pretty useful because it can apply any built-in Gimp filter to all layers.

I was using Aviutl today and found how to export a clip as PNG's. (export with ffmpeg > video encoding> Profile> PNG sequence
Better put them in a folder as well)

I notice Gimp-GAP is in the Ubuntu 20.04 repository but its version 2.6.

GAP = Gimp Animation Package is powerful - but it is difficult to learn how to use it well (I have only read now that "MPlayer based extraction" is only to save the frames as images on the disk - which was successful by the experiment - but in fact it is probably an error for Windows: it creates a file * .sh instead of *. bat). Good video editors are actually easier to use.

@Tas_mania: Unfortunately 'Filter all Layers' - it can apply some filters Gimp to all layers.

I did eventually get GAP 2.7 and mplayer working. You do need to set up the environmental variables.

Using an old (ancient) version of mplayer, about the same age as the plugin. I pulled one out of my archive of 'old-stuff'

Zipped and on dropbox https://www.dropbox.com/s/5myf9t55xg229 ... r.zip?dl=0 Let me know if any problems there. It is 20 MB zipped

This a demo using Win7 64 bit (just to show all the old 32bit files still works) and Gimp 2.8.22

https://youtu.be/tv2DeLLCq3Y 4 minutes

There is no guarantee that old version of mplayer will decode modern videos. A better tool, with a GUI, to extact a range of frames is Avidemux.

Same goes for Debian. I have yet to see a good reason to install it though.

Hi Rich2005.

The model solution - although in my portable Gimp-2.8.22 it always creates images in the bin directory - not in the tmp directory (for me a trifle).
For Gimp-2.10.20 and Win10, if I use the same files, it creates a * .bat file (so the MPlayer version is also valid) but deletes it before execution - it's possible that it is because of msys64/mingw64 or numerous Gimp versions installed.

I previously used:

Mplayer:
https://sourceforge.net/projects/portab ... 0Portable/
Codecs:
https://mplayerhq.hu/MPlayer/releases/codecs/?C=M;O=D

Thank You Rich2005 for Your support in solving the problem.

Actually means "GNU's not Unix!". Unless you mean this.

Rich2005 posted this interesting post: viewtopic.php?f=8&t=18461&start=0#p252157 I've tested and it works surprisingly well. I have ffmpeg installed system wide as do most Linux users. The only problem is it won't respect Alpha Channel for some reason. That and the fact that you can't set in and out points. It's still an interesting discovery non the less. It's worth looking into just the same.

ofnuts - I changed my post to 'GNU's not Unix'. (Actually GNU is Unix).

Here is what the GAP 'Filter all Layers' looks like.


Looks like G'MIC can import video using the method suggested by racer-x and Rich.

Looks like the Windows Gimp-GAP was cross-compiled on an openSuse system.

I just compiled gimp-gap for the last Ubuntu running Gimp 2.10.x
This has the 'Video' menu entry and the 'Filter all Layers' menu entry.

Download here.
It has one dependency - sudo apt-get install libfaac0

One of the Filter all Layers 'alien map' was changed in the latest Gimps.
I found how to install older filters dropped by Gimp. In this case I put the old filter in
/usr/lib/gimp/2.0/plug-ins/alien-map
make executable


BTW This is for the installed Gimp not an appimage.

Thank You Tas_mania.
Works very well for Gimp-2.10.20 (own build with Python2).
Have You ever tried on Ubuntu: "Cross compilation for Windows"?:

(quote from the site: https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gimp-gap/ )

GIMP-GAP was succesfully built for Windows 64 bit systems
on a 64 bit Linux Host by following those cross compilation steps:

o) installed most dependency libs from openSuSE 13.1 windows 64 bit
Note that openSuSE already provides many cross compiled libraries for Windows.
The url for the win 64 bit repository is:
http://download.opensuse.org/repositori ... SUSE_13.1/
o) have a script to setup environment varbles
(PREFIX, LD_LIBRARY_PATH and other stuff see the gimp wiki crosscompile page)
o) crosscompiled some dependency libs that were not provided as binary by openSUSE 13.1
o) crosscompiled gimp-2.8.10 (see gimp wiki crosscompile page)

o) configure GAP for cross compilation:

-) Add the options:
--enable-cross-compile --target-os=mingw32 --arch=x86_64
to the file: extern_libs/configure_options_ffmpeg_win32.txt

-) run configure (or autogen.sh) with the following configure options:
./configure --prefix=$PREFIX --host=x86_64-w64-mingw32 --disable-libmpeg3 --disable-gui-thread-su

But now I wonder if this is possible for MathMap.

Hi Marero, Gimp-Gap and MathMap are similar. Extensive plugins written in C. It must be possible to cross-compile for Windows in Linux.
The code is there but nobody has been able to do it so far.
Another posibility is MS Azure.

I get frightened by the jargon (tech-speak) of Azure. There is no charge for open source projects apparently. Maybe it will happen this year.
Hope so.

Thanks for the gimp-gap Tas_mania!