bredies: i once tried to make something similar to what you are doing above, two flipped images with a gradient background and a gap in between and i tried very hard to reproduce the same gradient but douldn't. i found a quick fix that worked for me but that may not be very proffessional, here is how:
1. start by making a rectangle tool selection of the edge of one of the wine bottle images and copy the selection. paste the selection to a new layer. the selection doesn't have to be very wide, in your case about 10px width would be enough, but it has to be full height.
2. use the scale tool,

, on the new pasted layer. drag it out in the horizontal direction only, to meet the edge of the other wine bottle image (you will have to anchor your transformation to see the result). in the screenshot i do this on a piece of a gimp chat banner, just drag it out horizontally - you need to make sure the width and height tabs are disconnected by clicking on the bracket next to the tabs.
here is the result of the transformation in the screenshot:
as you can see, it worked fine enough.